Scream Too! trophy is one of the Silver Trophies in Until Dawn. You can earn this trophy during the fifth chapter – Prey, when Sam is chased by the Maniac. If she doesn’t escape, the Maniac will kill her, and Scream Too! Trophy will be unlocked. In this case you’ll not be able to collect all collectibles in Chapter 7 – Violence. You should choose the following choices if you want Sam to survive: jump over the bed, run, pull the shelf with wine bottles to get the handle, hide in the elevator.