Help Mary or not in RDR2 is a choice you get in the game. What you choose will make the difference between starting the We Loved Once and True quest in Red Dead Redemption 2, and can even lock you out of some missions. Our Red Dead Redemption 2 Help Mary or Not – What to Choose guide will show you what happens in either of the choices with Arthur’s ex, and how to complete each one. Needless to say: SPOILER WARNING.
What Happens When you Help Mary Find Her Brother in RDR2?
If you choose to help Mary (Arthur’s ex in Red Dead Redemption 2) find her brother Jamie, you’re gonna have to find the Chelonians. They are basically a cult that Jamie has fallen into, and Mary wants you to rescue him. She tells you that they’re somewhere in Cumberland Forest, and, indeed, they are. The game will mark the location for you, in the northeast of Cumberland Forest. The Chelonians are caming out on a cliff top.
When you approach the cult, you’ll have a brief dialogue with them. After that, Jamie is going to book it on his horse, and you’ll have to give chase. Follow him as closely as you can, and don’t give up on the pursuit. At one point, Jamie is gonna ride across the railroad tracks, and a short cutscene will play. Jamie will threaten suicide, and you’ll have to use Dead Eye to shoot the gun out of his hand without harming him. The only thing left to do then is ride with Jamie back to Mary’s house.
RDR2 Mary’s Brother Choice – What Happens if you Decline?
If you decline to help Mary find her brother in Red Dead Redemption 2, that’s where this quest ends. The two will share a few gentle words, talk about how they miss each other, and part ways. And, that’s that for Mary and Arthur. What’s important to note here is that this choice might lock you out of another mission. If you choose to help Maryie, later on, she’ll ask you to save her father, too. So, you should know that before you just give her the cold shoulder. In this game, accepting to help people is always the better choice. Ultimately, this is up to you to decide.
There are several other choices in Red Dead Redemption 2 that you might be puzzling about. Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered there, too, with Split Up or Leave Bait – Bear Hunting, Kill or Spare O’Driscoll in Barn, Kill or Help Blackwater Man, and other guides.
If you end up getting stuck at another point, you might want to check out some of the other guides we have. We've written about mysteries like the missing person Gavin, the Rhodes Gunsmith prisoner, the locked door at Valentine doctor. We also have instructional guides that show how to rob stores without getting bounty or where to sell jewelry and gold bars. If it's collectibles or key items you're after, we've found all the Penny Dreadful comic books, Chick's treasure map location, or that famous pipe for Dutch. Finally, if you don't care to explore the map yourself, you could take a look at our Watson's Cabin and Catfish Jackson's Homestead locations guides. In the latest Red Dead Online Moonshiners Update you'll have a chance to find Navy Revolver and Best Shack Locations.